Best Garnishes for Classic Cocktails: Old Fashioned, Manhattan & Martini
By The Aged And Amber Spirits Team
A garnish isn't just presentation — for these three classics in particular, it plays a genuine role in the finished drink's aroma and flavor.
Old Fashioned: Orange Peel
The traditional garnish is an orange peel, expressed (twisted to release citrus oils) directly over the drink before being either dropped in or perched on the rim. The oils released during expression add a real aromatic citrus note that complements the drink's sugar and bitters — a functional step, not just decoration. A brandied cherry is sometimes added as well, though purists debate whether it belongs in a truly classic version.
Manhattan: Brandied Cherry
A high-quality brandied or cocktail cherry (Luxardo is the most commonly recommended premium brand) is the traditional Manhattan garnish, adding a subtle sweetness and depth that complements the drink's whiskey-and-sweet-vermouth base. The cherry is meant to be eaten at the end, adding a genuine flavor payoff rather than serving purely as decoration.
Martini: Olive or Lemon Twist
The two classic Martini garnishes serve genuinely different roles: olives add a savory, briny note (especially pronounced in a Dirty Martini), while a lemon twist adds bright citrus aromatics without changing the drink's fundamental flavor the way olive brine can. Choosing between them is a real style decision, not simply presentation.
Why Garnish Quality Matters
A cheap, artificially colored maraschino cherry delivers a noticeably different (and generally worse) result than a genuine Luxardo or similarly high-quality brandied cherry — the garnish is a real ingredient in the finished drink, not an afterthought, and quality differences show up directly in flavor.
Building a Garnish Kit
Keeping good citrus on hand for fresh peels and twists, a jar of quality cocktail cherries, and a jar of good olives (plain or stuffed, depending on preference) covers the garnishing needs for the vast majority of classic cocktails you're likely to make regularly.
Shop the Collection
Bar Essentials